diff --git a/front_end/panels/recorder/components/SelectButton.test.ts b/front_end/panels/recorder/components/SelectButton.test.ts
index aff827891d..706ba99f41 100644
--- a/front_end/panels/recorder/components/SelectButton.test.ts
+++ b/front_end/panels/recorder/components/SelectButton.test.ts
@@ -3,7 +3,6 @@
 // found in the LICENSE file.
 
 import {renderElementIntoDOM} from '../../../testing/DOMHelpers.js';
-import * as Menus from '../../../ui/components/menus/menus.js';
 import * as RenderCoordinator from '../../../ui/components/render_coordinator/render_coordinator.js';
 
 import * as RecorderComponents from './components.js';
@@ -45,12 +44,11 @@ describe('SelectButton', () => {
     await RenderCoordinator.done();
     const dispatcherSpy = sinon.spy(component, 'dispatchEvent');
     const selectMenu = component.shadowRoot?.querySelector(
-        'devtools-select-menu',
+        'select',
     );
     assert.exists(selectMenu);
-    selectMenu.dispatchEvent(
-        new Menus.SelectMenu.SelectMenuItemSelectedEvent('item1'),
-    );
+    selectMenu.value = 'item1';
+    selectMenu.dispatchEvent(new Event('change'));
 
     dispatcherSpy.calledOnceWithExactly(
         RecorderComponents.SelectButton.SelectMenuSelectedEvent as unknown as sinon.SinonMatcher);
diff --git a/front_end/panels/recorder/components/SelectButton.ts b/front_end/panels/recorder/components/SelectButton.ts
index 4c919ce61b..bdc5f67e7f 100644
--- a/front_end/panels/recorder/components/SelectButton.ts
+++ b/front_end/panels/recorder/components/SelectButton.ts
@@ -7,9 +7,9 @@ import '../../../ui/components/menus/menus.js';
 import * as Platform from '../../../core/platform/platform.js';
 import type {LocalizedString} from '../../../core/platform/UIString.js';
 import * as Buttons from '../../../ui/components/buttons/buttons.js';
-import * as Dialogs from '../../../ui/components/dialogs/dialogs.js';
 import * as ComponentHelpers from '../../../ui/components/helpers/helpers.js';
-import type * as Menus from '../../../ui/components/menus/menus.js';
+// eslint-disable-next-line rulesdir/es-modules-import
+import inspectorCommonStylesRaw from '../../../ui/legacy/inspectorCommon.css.js';
 import * as Lit from '../../../ui/lit/lit.js';
 import * as VisualLogging from '../../../ui/visual_logging/visual_logging.js';
 import * as Models from '../models/models.js';
@@ -17,6 +17,10 @@ import type * as Actions from '../recorder-actions/recorder-actions.js';
 
 import selectButtonStylesRaw from './selectButton.css.js';
 
+// TODO(crbug.com/391381439): Fully migrate off of constructed style sheets.
+const inspectorCommonStyles = new CSSStyleSheet();
+inspectorCommonStyles.replaceSync(inspectorCommonStylesRaw.cssText);
+
 // TODO(crbug.com/391381439): Fully migrate off of constructed style sheets.
 const selectButtonStyles = new CSSStyleSheet();
 selectButtonStyles.replaceSync(selectButtonStylesRaw.cssText);
@@ -114,7 +118,7 @@ export class SelectButton extends HTMLElement {
   };
 
   connectedCallback(): void {
-    this.#shadow.adoptedStyleSheets = [selectButtonStyles];
+    this.#shadow.adoptedStyleSheets = [inspectorCommonStyles, selectButtonStyles];
     void ComponentHelpers.ScheduledRender.scheduleRender(this, this.#render);
   }
 
@@ -174,26 +178,29 @@ export class SelectButton extends HTMLElement {
   }
 
   #handleSelectMenuSelect(
-      evt: Menus.SelectMenu.SelectMenuItemSelectedEvent,
+      evt: Event,
       ): void {
-    this.dispatchEvent(new SelectMenuSelectedEvent(evt.itemValue as string));
-    void ComponentHelpers.ScheduledRender.scheduleRender(this, this.#render);
+    if (evt.target instanceof HTMLSelectElement) {
+      this.dispatchEvent(new SelectMenuSelectedEvent(evt.target.value as string));
+      void ComponentHelpers.ScheduledRender.scheduleRender(this, this.#render);
+    }
   }
 
   #renderSelectItem(
       item: SelectButtonItem,
       selectedItem: SelectButtonItem,
       ): Lit.TemplateResult {
+    const selected = item.value === selectedItem.value;
     // clang-format off
     return html`
-      <devtools-menu-item
+      <option
       .title=${item.label()}
-      .value=${item.value}
-      .selected=${item.value === selectedItem.value}
+      value=${item.value}
+      ?selected=${selected}
       jslog=${VisualLogging.item(Platform.StringUtilities.toKebabCase(item.value)).track({click: true})}
       >${
-        item.label()
-      }</devtools-menu-item>
+        (selected && item.buttonLabel) ? item.buttonLabel() : item.label()
+      }</option>
     `;
     // clang-format on
   }
@@ -204,9 +211,9 @@ export class SelectButton extends HTMLElement {
       ): Lit.TemplateResult {
     // clang-format off
     return html`
-      <devtools-menu-group .name=${group.name}>
+      <optgroup label=${group.name}>
         ${group.items.map(item => this.#renderSelectItem(item, selectedItem))}
-      </devtools-menu-group>
+      </optgroup>
     `;
     // clang-format on
   }
@@ -236,31 +243,21 @@ export class SelectButton extends HTMLElement {
     Lit.render(
       html`
       <div class="select-button" title=${ifDefined(this.#getTitle(menuLabel))}>
-      <devtools-select-menu
-          title=""
-          class=${classMap(classes)}
-          @selectmenuselected=${this.#handleSelectMenuSelect}
-          ?disabled=${this.#props.disabled}
-          .showArrow=${true}
-          .sideButton=${false}
-          .showSelectedItem=${true}
-          .disabled=${this.#props.disabled}
-          .buttonTitle=${() => html`${menuLabel}`}
-          .position=${Dialogs.Dialog.DialogVerticalPosition.BOTTOM}
-          .horizontalAlignment=${
-            Dialogs.Dialog.DialogHorizontalAlignment.RIGHT
-          }
-        >
-          ${
-            hasGroups
-              ? this.#props.groups.map(group =>
-                  this.#renderSelectGroup(group, selectedItem),
-                )
-              : this.#props.items.map(item =>
-                  this.#renderSelectItem(item, selectedItem),
-                )
-          }
-        </devtools-select-menu>
+      <select
+      class=${classMap(classes)}
+      ?disabled=${this.#props.disabled}
+      jslog=${VisualLogging.dropDown('network-conditions').track({change: true})}
+      @change=${this.#handleSelectMenuSelect}>
+        ${
+          hasGroups
+            ? this.#props.groups.map(group =>
+                this.#renderSelectGroup(group, selectedItem),
+              )
+            : this.#props.items.map(item =>
+                this.#renderSelectItem(item, selectedItem),
+              )
+        }
+    </select>
         ${
           selectedItem
             ? html`
diff --git a/test/e2e/recorder/helpers.ts b/test/e2e/recorder/helpers.ts
index b06b4125fe..2df4f02b75 100644
--- a/test/e2e/recorder/helpers.ts
+++ b/test/e2e/recorder/helpers.ts
@@ -11,12 +11,11 @@ import {openPanelViaMoreTools} from '../../../test/e2e/helpers/settings-helpers.
 import {
   $,
   click,
-  clickElement,
   getBrowserAndPages,
   getTestServerPort,
   goToResource,
   platform,
-  timeout,
+  selectOption,
   waitFor,
   waitForAria,
 } from '../../../test/shared/helper.js';
@@ -234,46 +233,15 @@ async function setCode(flow: string) {
   }, flow);
 }
 
-async function waitForDialogAnimationEnd(root?: ElementHandle) {
-  const ANIMATION_TIMEOUT = 2000;
-  const dialog = await waitFor('dialog[open]', root);
-  const animationPromise = dialog.evaluate((dialog: Element) => {
-    return new Promise<void>(resolve => {
-      dialog.addEventListener('animationend', () => resolve(), {once: true});
-    });
-  });
-  await Promise.race([animationPromise, timeout(ANIMATION_TIMEOUT)]);
-}
-
 export async function clickSelectButtonItem(itemLabel: string, root: string) {
   const selectMenu = await waitFor(root);
   const selectMenuButton = await waitFor(
-      'devtools-select-menu-button',
+      'select',
       selectMenu,
   );
-  const animationEndPromise = waitForDialogAnimationEnd();
-  await click('#arrow', {root: selectMenuButton});
-  await animationEndPromise;
 
-  const selectMenuItems = await selectMenu.$$('pierce/devtools-menu-item');
-  const selectMenuItemIndex =
-      await Promise
-          .all(
-              selectMenuItems.map(
-                  selectMenuItem => selectMenuItem.evaluate(element => element.textContent?.trim()),
-                  ),
-              )
-          .then(
-              elements => elements.findIndex(elementText => elementText === itemLabel),
-          );
+  void selectOption(await selectMenuButton.toElement('select'), itemLabel);
 
-  if (selectMenuItemIndex === -1) {
-    throw new Error(
-        `Select menu item for label "${itemLabel}" is not found in "${root}"`,
-    );
-  }
-
-  await clickElement(selectMenuItems[selectMenuItemIndex]);
   await click('devtools-button', {root: selectMenu});
 }